The game jar: let the family draw tonight's game instead of arguing about it

BoarditOct 16, 2026

The longest part of many family game nights is choosing the game. One child wants the same one as last week, a parent wants something short, and by the time everyone agrees, half the evening has gone. A game jar takes that decision out of anyone's hands.

The idea is simple. Write each game on a slip of paper, fold it, and put it in a jar. Before you play, someone draws a slip. Whatever comes out is tonight's game.

Why it works

A draw is fair in a way a vote never is. Nobody wins the argument, because there is no argument. Younger children in particular accept "the jar picked it" far more easily than "your sister picked it". And the person who draws the slip gets a small moment of drama, which is a good start to the evening.

Fill the jar well

The jar only works if every slip is a game the whole family can actually play tonight. So before a game goes in, check three things:

  1. Everyone can play it. Look at the player count and the youngest player's age. A game for four does not go in the jar of a family of six.
  2. It fits the evening. If game night is ninety minutes, a three-hour game does not go in.
  3. Someone knows the rules. A slip that leads to forty minutes of reading the rulebook is a slip nobody will be happy to draw.

Eight to twelve slips is a good size. Fewer and the same games come up too often. More and some games never appear.

Add some online games

Board games on a shelf are only half the options. If some of your slips are online games, a site like Boardit, which I build, keeps them to a link and a room code. That matters when a grandparent or a cousin joins from another city, because the slip can be a game everyone plays on their own phone or laptop.

Write the player limit on those slips too. On Boardit, Ludo is for two to four players, Snakes and Ladders for two to eight, and Draw and Guess for two to twelve. A slip that says "Ludo, up to 4" saves a disappointed fifth player.

House rules for the jar

  • One redraw per night. If the slip is a game nobody is in the mood for, the family can put it back and draw once more. Only once, or the jar loses its power.
  • Drawn slips stay out until every slip has been played. Then they all go back in. This stops one favourite coming up three weeks in a row.
  • Anyone can add a slip, but only on the day after game night, never right before. That stops the jar being stuffed in the moment.
  • The youngest draws first in a new round of slips. It is a small honour, and it helps.

A jar for short nights

Some families keep two jars: one for full game nights and one for school nights, with games under twenty minutes. On a busy evening you draw from the small jar, and nobody has to argue about whether there is time.

What the jar cannot fix

A jar decides which game, not how people behave once it starts. If game nights end in tears, the problem is usually the kind of game, such as long games where one player is knocked out early, not the choosing. Take those slips out, and the jar will do the rest.

The limit of a method

I have not measured whether a jar shortens the argument at your table. It is a method, not a study. Try it for four weeks and you will know.

Ahmed Moaz builds Boardit, a free browser game site.


Never miss a post

Get new writing sent to your inbox.

Subscribe