How voting works in a spy game online: calls, accusations, runoffs and points

The vote is the climax of any spy game online. Clues have been given, suspicions raised, and now the table must decide. In Who's the Spy, the vote has a few rules that surprise new players, from who can call it to what happens on a tie. Here they are, in

BoarditOct 22, 2026

The vote is the climax of any spy game online. Clues have been given, suspicions raised, and now the table must decide. In Who's the Spy, the vote has a few rules that surprise new players, from who can call it to what happens on a tie. Here they are, in the order they happen.

Who can call a vote?

The table does, together. A vote can be requested after every two laps of clues, which means each player has spoken twice. A short window follows, ten seconds long, in which any player can ask for a vote. The vote begins only when more than half of the players have asked. If they have not, the clues resume for two more laps. When everyone shares one phone, the host decides when to vote instead.

The two-lap rule prevents the game from being decided on one clue, and the majority rule means the table has to agree that it has heard enough.

What happens when the vote opens?

Every player chooses who they think is the spy, with 45 seconds on the clock. You cannot vote for yourself. When the time is up, or when everyone has voted, the votes are counted, and the tally appears for a few seconds so the table can see how it went.

What if there is a tie?

A tie goes to a runoff between the tied players only, a fairer way to settle a close vote than throwing it out. Everyone votes again, choosing from those names. If the runoff also ties, nobody is ejected. The same happens if nobody was named at all, for instance because every clock ran out.

Who scores what?

There are three routes to a point, and they are independent:

  • Every player who named a spy in the vote scores a point.
  • Every spy who was not the player ejected scores a point. With more than one spy, a spy who is not the one voted out still scores.
  • A lone spy who is caught gets a single guess at the word, chosen from ten options, and a right guess earns another point.

Then the round closes and a new deal follows.

What happens with more than one spy?

A host may seat more than one spy, as many as half the table. The vote ejects one player. A voter who named either spy scores, and a spy who was not ejected scores as well, so a round can pay several people at once.

How should you vote?

  1. Think about whose clues felt late, vague or echoing.
  2. Notice who defended too quickly.
  3. Vote with a reason, so that you can explain it.
  4. Do not follow the first accusation unless you believe it.

What does the scoring teach?

That voting is worth doing, even when you are unsure. A vote for the wrong player costs you nothing, while a right vote scores. The system rewards participation and reading people. It also rewards spies who stay calm, since a spy who escapes scores as well.

How long does a round take?

Compared with a voice vote around a table, the clock adds structure. The vote adds about a minute to a round: ten seconds to call, 45 to vote and a few for the tally. Add the spy's 30-second guess if they are caught, and the reveal. A round with four players is about five minutes from deal to result.

Where can you play?

You can try the whole sequence at Boardit, a free imposter game online with friends, from three players to eight, or up to twelve around one phone. The table runs the clocks, counts the votes and keeps the score, which makes it a tidy social deduction game for an evening.

Why the vote feels like a trial

The vote turns a conversation into a decision. It is brief, tense and decisive, and it is why the game feels like a trial in miniature.

Ahmed Moaz builds Boardit, a free browser game site.


Never miss a post

Get new writing sent to your inbox.

Subscribe